The War Profiteers - War Crimes, Kidnappings & Torture

 

August 18th, 2009 - ‘Pendleton 8’ Figure Protests Loss of Attorney

News article from North County Times

Summary of the Hashim Al-Zobaie Killing

‘Pendleton 8’ Figure Protests Loss of Attorney

Attorney’s departure from legal team now part of appellate review

 

By Mark Walker

North County Times

August 18, 2009

 

Camp Pendleton - A Marine convicted in the 2006 killing of an Iraqi man he suspected was an insurgent said Tuesday he didn't know that one of his attorneys, who departed on the eve of his trial, could have been ordered to remain at his defense table.

 

Former Sgt. and now Pvt. Larry Hutchins III took the stand and testified under oath for the first time, telling a military judge that he would have considered asking the attorney, former Marine Capt. Gabriel Bass, to put off his scheduled retirement.

 

"I joined to be a grunt and that's what I was," Hutchins testified during a hearing ordered by the Navy-Marine Corps Court of Appeals to determine whether Bass was improperly removed. "How would I have known to raise the issue that I could keep Captain Bass?"

 

Hutchins spent about 35 minutes on the stand, testifying in a calm and even voice that he had established a good rapport with Bass and had believed the attorney would remain on his legal team after his retirement date, which came a few weeks before the trial.

 

"I figured he would come back," the 25-year-old native of Plymouth, Mass., said. "I was very surprised not to see him there."

 

Hutchins did not testify at the July 2007 trial where he was convicted of murder, conspiracy and kidnapping.

 

Prosecutors contend Bass was replaced by an experienced trial attorney and that Hutchins never protested Bass's removal and, therefore, no error was committed.

 

Hutchins is the key figure in the so-called "Pendleton 8" case involving six other Marines and a Navy corpsman he led in the Iraqi village of Hamdania during the height of the Iraq war.

 

Each man from the 3rd Battalion, 5th Marine Regiment squad was charged with murder and related offenses in the April 2006 incident.

 

Five pleaded guilty to a variety of reduced charges and were free by mid-2007. Two others were convicted at trial but sentenced to time served while awaiting trial. Hutchins was the only man sentenced to prison, initially receiving a 15-year term that has since been reduced to 11 years.

 

Attorneys are now working to have his conviction set aside, arguing among other things that the release of Bass was improper and is grounds to order a new trial. Tuesday's hearing was ordered by the appellate court to gather more information on that aspect of the appeal.

 

The base courtroom was filled with supporters of Hutchins, who was returned to Camp Pendleton last week from the military prison at Fort Leavenworth, Kan.

 

"I'm here to show my support for Larry because I believe in him and I believe he got a bad deal," said Skip Franklin. "He was trained to do a job and he did it."

 

Hutchins' parents, Larry and Kathi, also were in the courtroom. They said base officials have relaxed rules so they can visit their son in the evenings before he is returned to Kansas to await word on his appeal.

 

Kathi Hutchins said that several of her son's original co-defendants attempted to visit him on Sunday, but were turned away by brig officials.

 

External link: http://www.nctimes.com/news/local/military/article_7d089d7c-ea4d-5d49-9ef5-ac8f62710b49.html

Back to news & media - year 2009

Back to main archive

Back to main index